A plunny for someday (possibly someday past)

[soc_puppet]

But first: Happy 40th anniversary to my parents, uh, yesterday! (I celebrated in person with them and a few dozen other people, no worries about me missing it in brickspace.)


H'okay, back to business. Some of the changes in fandom over the past 20+ years came up on Tumblr, and I shared both a trope I haven't seen in a while, and the idle thought I had towards sporking it but never got around to:

I still want to do a subversion of this particular trope I remember from slash/yaoi fandom back in the day: Your preferred same gender ship had to go undercover as a couple at a gay bar. I feel like it became a less common trope as homophobia decreased? It was also usually part of a fandom that involved criminal investigation of some sort.

Anyway, one day I really want to write that trope, except:

Character A is particularly squirrely about going

Doesn't have a good explanation but insists that they're not homophobic (and may have actual receipts to back it up)

Ends up unable to get out of it

When the two of them arrive at the bar, you learn that Character A is a regular there and has been vocally pining after someone who matches the description of Character B

But some part of me has been reluctant because people won't recognize the trope anymore and realize that I'm lovingly sporking it, and apparently that's enough to ruin some of my interest in writing it? Like a part of me insists that the trope in question was a "time and place" kind of thing, and we're no longer in that time or place, so I shouldn't do it. And I know I shouldn't care, but like. It's not like brains make sense at the best of times, so here I am, I guess.

I still pine for that idea, but yeah. Brains.

Anyhow, any of you have ideas that you didn't get around to and now just no longer seem like they have a place?

Comments

[redsixwing]

*heeeeheheheheh* would read. Would very much read.

I definitely have ideas that no longer have a place. One is an AMV idea (we don't call them AMVs any more, apparently, and the band is no longer popular or even well known, the song hasn't been on the radio for some decades.)

But if I ever get the time/skill, I'd still like to make it, if only for my own satisfaction.

[soc_puppet]

If I ever end up in a fandom it would work for again, I will totally think about it! And then dedicate the fic to everyone who recognizes the trope I'm riffing on.

Oh man, AMVs! There are several that I want to exist, but I don't think I'm going to ever pick up the skills to make them. (WTF do we call them instead of AMVs? Has the name changed because the concept of fan-made music videos has escaped containment from anime?)

[redsixwing]

Excellent x'D

I've seen "fan edits" now? That surprised me when it referred to a full length music video (that is, the full length of the song) rather than a 20-second cut, but that seems to be the latest thing. I do think the escape of the music video to non-anime fandoms sparked the change.

[jesse_the_k]

I would read the hell out of that!

This trope is live and kicking in BBC Sherlock and

….back from 60 minutes trawling my bookmarks without evidence /o\

[soc_puppet]

I'm increasingly tempted to write the hell out of it, but another part of my problem is that I'm not really in a fandom it would work for, and haven't been for a while. If I ever wander into one it'll work for again, though, I'll definitely be giving it more thought!


😂 I'm tempted to ask around more widely, just to see if it really has disappeared. The "not being in fandoms it would work well for as a trope" thing probably doesn't help me here.

[jesse_the_k]

Oooo! fancake, home of carefully tagged themed rec lists, might have something (grazed these but none are my fandoms)

Undercover as a couple as well as Trope Subversion/Inversion