soc_puppet: Words "Humorless Feminist" in pink (Humorless Feminist)
[personal profile] soc_puppet
I was totally going to do a post warning about how the main auction at [livejournal.com profile] help_haiti was closing soon, except A) I slept in until noon today, since school was canceled, and B) I got the closing time mixed up, not realizing it meant noon instead of midnight. W-whoops.

In any case! Bidding ended today a few hours ago. Here's something you may want to take a look at: Auction Closing Procedures. I will definitely be reading it closely myself at some point in the very near future.


In other linkblogging news: Liberal Bloggers to Obama and Dems: We Told You So


Also, while I normally have the utmost respect for Neil Gaiman, I really can't approve of his use of the word "bitch." (Trigger Warning for last link.)

Thanks to a [livejournal.com profile] lightbird777, I was expecting the Depp-seems-to-be-on-Team-Polanski thing. Even if I don't care much for Gaiman's solo work, however, this feels like more of a slap in the face.

Edit: Neil Gaiman, when negative reactions to his use of "bitch" were presented to him, has just said he will try to do better in the future". While he doesn't seem to feel contrite about its use in the George R. R. Martin post (where it is definitely used to mean "Someone who is at your disposal to use however you like", with the sexual implications all but out loud), it is at least slightly encouraging.

Edit 2: Aaaaand now we're moving backwards. *sigh*

-Trigger Warning-

Dear Mr. Gaiman,

On the off-chance that you are reading this post, I would like to take the opportunity to be a little clearer:

It makes me uncomfortable that you are using the term "bitch" to convey your sense of safety as a writer. As a woman, I am not afforded this same level of safety in regards to my basic personhood. There is as much as a twenty-five percent chance that I will become someone's "bitch" in my lifetime, and not in the sense you use it. It makes me cringe when I think of my friends and family members who have the same odds, or who already have been someone's "bitch".

The fact that you are comparing this to writing, or the idea that someone "has" to write something, is alienating and hurtful to me. I hope that, as someone who ostensibly makes a career out of being able to see things from the point of view of another person, fictional or otherwise, you may yet be willing to consider things from mine.

Date: 2010-01-22 02:09 am (UTC)
meigui: fan... something: Sir Leon; Merlin; BBC (this is my "what" face)
From: [personal profile] meigui
Actually, I was wrong--Neil got the connection, but he was being defensive because of a delicate situation that was demanding the majority of his attention at the time (and still is)--Melissa McEwan has posted a followup in response. I think in this case I'm inclined to be sympathetic towards GNeil for his twitter responses--it's understandably difficult to engage in this kind of discussion when you're worried about your cat who is possibly dying at the veterinary hospital actually dying, period, lol I can has reading comprehension.

Etymology is my hobby! iloveitsomuch :3

Actually, it's funny--in its current usage, "bitch" seems to mean two things that are opposite--both "submissive person" and "pushy person", generally trending male in the first case and trending female in the second, though not necessarily. (Which. Lolproblematic again but!) There's a technical name for when you have a word that's its own antonym like that, but I can't remember it, and that frustrates me :(
Edited Date: 2010-01-22 02:18 am (UTC)

Date: 2010-01-22 04:07 am (UTC)
meigui: original: Mountain Witch and Tiger (these things have rules)
From: [personal profile] meigui
Mmm, I find it's often better to be forgiving than not; for one thing, we all make mistakes, and we all sometimes cause hurt without meaning to, especially when we ourselves are hurting. I don't know. For me, it's partly from wanting to be fair to them and whatever aspect of their experience of which I might be unaware or unable to conceptualize on a personal level, but also partly as a personal defense mechanism. Double consciousness will drive me nuts if and when I let it keep me poised to jump all the time, which sometimes I do when I get a particularly bad headspace, and it does nothing at all to help get me out of it.

Actually, can I PM you about this? I have some personal anecdotes to share that I think might be useful for you, but I'm not sure it's appropriate to discuss in a public post.


You know, I think it's telling that usually the woman-as-submissive and man-as-pushy usages are--in my experience, anyway--found far more commonly in countercultural contexts, particularly GLBT communities or communities that have a lot of people who are also part of GLBT communities; so, actually, you might have something there.

December 2025

S M T W T F S
 12 3456
78 910 111213
1415 161718 19 20
21 22 2324252627
28293031   

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Dec. 24th, 2025 12:52 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios